Losing my edge to anti-hipster prejudice
For how much
longer will people sneer at "hipsters"? You’d
think, er, it'd maybe go out of fashion or something. But no, it's still with
us. It's the new cultural prejudice that's safe to indulge. Even revel in. Supposed "liberals", who will studiously avoid crass remarks about race, gender,
disability or age, will go out of their way to insult small pockets of people
they've decided deserve it. Should a conversational opportunity present itself - usually all it takes in London, for example, is for someone to mention Dalston or Shoreditch - then you'll usually hear the anti-hipster sneerers piping up immediately. "Oh, it's all hipsters in Dalston. Let's go somewhere else." "God, I'm so sick of the skinny jeans and all the silly hipsters" (a word-for-word quote I heard recently). Or you'll see self-satisfied hashtagged tweets from the sneerers describing something they've seen and immediately pigeonholed with a knowing #Shoreditch. (Yep, you're the boss, the neutral observer, immune to all this immaturity and amused by it in your laconic way, but always ready to chop it down to size).
Yes, the
put-downs are fun (supposedly), they're easy. And they're er, what? Funny? No, not really. Or
maybe just moderately, to the confirmed anti-hipster, but even then only in an excruciatingly grim way (like racist jokes). So they're group-confirming or something? Perhaps they bind a little cohort together with a shared idea of what's "normal" or "valid". Or what's "fashionable
without being ridiculous or contrived". Hmm. It's certainly true that
anti-hipsterism is a shared thing and is revalidated by people laughing (ie sneering)
along with the joker. Hipster
attacks are supposed to be wonderfully watertight, insulating the attacker from
any suspicion of hipsterism and immediately placing them in a "safe" zone. And
I think there's a double game going on here where the anti-hipster brigade
like to feel hip enough to be in fairly close proximity to their targets while
retaining the right to slag them or their "hipster" locations off whenever the urge
arises. All in all
it's a nasty business. It's a sort of cultural racism for the urban middle classes (or
rather, a superior, smug subset). Every time I weave through Shoreditch on my
way to a gig I recall the anti-hipster put-downs. Small-minded liberals
betraying their own illiberality and insecurity. It makes you warm to people
who are their targets, possibly playing in a band that night. And in the
end, apart from the fact that some people simply get a kick out of putting
other people down, I reckon anti-hipsterism is about insecurity. As LCD
Soundsystem's superb Losing My Edge has it, the anti-hipster bigots might
simply be afraid that they're losing their edge to "the kids ... coming up behind
.... to better-looking people with better ideas and more talent". Ah, but then again, James Murphy is a New York hipster, so what does he know?
Comments
Post a Comment